You should settle an auto accident case when subsequent to the time an offer is received by you and/or your attorney, you are completely satisfied with the offer, and not just the offer, the amount of money you’re going to end up with in your pocket after all fees and medical expenses are paid. A lot of attorney’s will tell you, hey I got you an offer of $50,000 let’s say, it’s a great offer, but if at the end of the day you’re going to end up with 3 or 4 or $5,000 that’s not a very good offer.
Therefore the most important thing you should be concerned of, and what you should consult with your attorney about, is the amount of money you’re going to end up with in your pocket, and at that time if you’re satisfied with that amount of money, would be the time you should settle your case.